Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nancy Peacock's avatar

There is a distinct parallel between 1930s Germany and 2025 America. And it is economics. Germans bought Hitters lies because they were broken by their post-World War 1 poverty. Today in America there is a comfortable class with stock portfolio retirement funds and then there is a forgotten group of people that have been left behind with stagnant wages and ever-increasing prices. These forgotten people believe that raising the minimum wage will make their Big Macs unaffordable and no one in the comfortable class wants them to know any differently. Then a two-bit reality show host convinces them that they would be able to join the comfortable class if only immigrants and people of color weren’t thwarting his efforts to help them get what is rightfully theirs.

In 1930s Germany, it was the Jews who were holding back poor Germans. In America, it is immigrants and people of color and liberals.

Same script, same scenario, just a different time period.

Expand full comment
CindyO in Texas's avatar

"And perhaps most of all, do we have the humility not to imagine that we are too intelligent or spiritual or informed not to become as hateful as we have seen other people become?"

You have pin-pointed exactly a parallel struggle (for lack of a better way to put it) that is constantly present as we resist the fascism that appears to have overtaken our country in such large numbers. It is the struggle not to give way to hate and loathing of those who voted for Trump.

So now I guess the job is to figure out a way to "teach" the other side to not give in to hate any more than they already have (which sounds just incredibly arrogant as I type this comment). I have no idea how to do this, but if we can't find a way to do it, I fear violence will be unavoidable.

Expand full comment
51 more comments...

No posts