Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rebecca Piffard's avatar

It meant a lot to read your post today. I’ve been a graphic artist 40+years. I’ve watched my value as a professional and an artist disintegrate even though I’ve kept up with all the technology.

Expand full comment
Terra M.'s avatar

I despise that tech bros have taken to call their latest gimmick "artificial intelligence".

It's not intelligent.

Here's what "AI" really is.

Remember refrigerator magnets that had words on them that you could arrange in any order you wanted to make poetry? Imagine a refrigerator so large it could hold the sum of human knowledge. Large Language Models (LLMs) are given the set of magnets and rearrange them on the refrigerator.

Nothing new is made. Nothing is spontaneously generated. It's just Mad Libs on a massive scale. And where do the magnets (words) actually come from? Human beings. How does the LLM get those magnets? Humans take them from other humans. This results in one set of humans passing off the work of other humans and hiding behind the sheer scale of it all.

What makes us human? Our ability to spontaneously believe in things that don't exist and bring those imaginary things into the world.

So why did we imagine and then invent computers? The human brain is a marvelous organ, but it has limits when it comes to data storage, retrieval, and processing. Computers compensate for those limits.

The problem comes when people forget where the ideas actually come from and confuse speed and/or reliability with creation.

We need artists of all kinds, or there will be no new ideas, nor any way to bring them into existence.

Expand full comment
20 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?